Building stuff every day ...

Speculation: Why social media accounts cannot be completely deleted

A recent Mastodon post raises concern about deleting social media accounts. TLDR: A Facebook account that was seemingly deleted back in 2017 still contained all of the personal data in 2026.

I recently had a similar experience with Google. About a year ago, my primary email address for friends and family was moved from Gmail to a paid email provider that offered better privacy. The contact information for my friends was moved to the new service, then all of the contacts were deleted from Google contacts. The Google email account was left active though because once in a while I use Google services. Recently, I was searching for an old friend's email address. After coming up fruitless, I thought to look back at Google Contacts. It showed 0 contacts. However, searching for the old friend in the Contacts search field yielded his email address (a Gmail address), along with addresses for some other old friends. Google seemed to remember that I corresponded with that old friend. The contacts appeared to be gone, yet these linkages to others still remained.

So, what is going on? I suspect that deleting a social media account is not the same as simply deleting an unwanted file from your hard drive. There's more to it.

The act of deleting information might delete some information, but not all of it. The less obvious or hidden part is that the personal data is still present in the accounts of other users. It's spread across the network in ways that cannot be deleted.

Let's go back to my example. I corresponded with a friend (Gmail to Gmail), then deleted my contact information. My contact information has been deleted. However, my friend still has correspondence from me saved in his Gmail account. My data in his account hasn't been deleted because it's his account, not mine. Google can quickly search across email accounts to find that this person is someone who I've corresponded with. Altogether, my data has only been partly deleted. There's still traces of my data in the accounts of other people that cannot be deleted. This is a network effect: my data is distributed across the network. Only some of my data is deleted - what I directly see - when my account is deleted.

There is relevance to psychology. The way long-term memory is stored in the brain takes this distributed approach. The information is spread across multiple brain regions. If one memory connection is lost, other connections in the network are still there to help keep the memory intact. This makes memory resilient.

I don't know for sure if this explanation is why I can find the email addresses of old friends even though I have deleted my contacts. I'm not a Google engineer.

It's an explanation that seems plausible from a neuroscience or network focused view. Perhaps it informs how we should think about network effects in online settings. It's similar to this recent argument that we should think of generative AI from a brain perspective rather than a computer science perspective to better understand it.

Thoughts? Leave a comment